This is part of 50 for 50, Editor Emeritus Patricia Calhoun’s series of 50 columns celebrating 50 years of Colorado history in honor of Westword’s 50th anniversary year.
On April 13, 1987, Gary Warren Hart stood at Red Rocks Amphitheatre and announced his campaign for the presidency to a winded press corps. Then an incumbent U.S. senator, the Colorado transplant had come in second to Walter Mondale in the 1984 Democratic campaign, and with popular New York Governor Mario Cuomo already declining to get in the 1988 race, Hart was automatically the frontrunner.
Four weeks later, his campaign was sunk … by a quick trip on the Monkey Business.
Hart was born in 1936 in Ottawa, Kansas, as Gary Hartpence. A graduate of Bethany Nazarene College, where he met his wife, he went on to Yale Divinity School, then Yale University Law School, where he lost the second half of his last name and gained a law degree. In 1964, he went to Washington, D.C., to work as an attorney for the United States Department of Justice, then became a special assistant to the solicitor of the Interior Department. In 1967, Hart moved to Colorado to join a prominent private law firm.
Sign up for the This Week’s Top Stories newsletter to get the latest stories delivered to your inbox
THANK YOU!
You're all set.
Editor's Picks
His life didn’t stay private for long. Hart was hired as the campaign manager for Sen. George McGovern’s 1972 presidential campaign, a move aided by new rules for primaries that benefited outsiders and hard work; Sen. Edmund Muskie’s early exit further boosted McGovern’s Democratic chances. But the North Dakota senator was obliterated in a landslide as Richard Nixon won a second term.
With the Republican Party soon buried by Watergate, Hart decided to challenge two-term incumbent Sen. Peter Dominick in 1974, and won 52.7% of the vote to Dominick’s 39.5%.
The 38-year-old Hart was compared to John F. Kennedy Jr. and labeled a rising star, one of the “Atari Democrats” who helped give the Democrats supermajorities in both houses of Congress. He landed on the Senate Armed Services Committee as well as the Environment and Public Works Committee and the Intelligence Committee, all positions that took advantage of Hart’s cool demeanor and intense intellect.
Even so, Hart didn’t have an easy time in 1980, when many congressional incumbents, including McGovern, lost their seats. Running against Republican Secretary of State Mary Estill Buchanan (who came as close as any woman has come to becoming a senator from Colorado), he squeaked by at 50.2%.
advertisement
advertisement
By 1984, Hart made his own run for the presidency, losing the nomination to Walter Mondale, who lost to incumbent Ronald Reagan. With Reagan term limited, Hart set his sights on the 1988 Presidential campaign. He skipped the 1986 Senate race, and instead concentrated on buffing up his positions, contacts and reputation.
But not enough. The day Hart announced his candidacy at Red Rocks, Newsweek published a story about Hart’s two trial separations from his wife, and coyly quoted a former advisor as saying a candidate was “always in jeopardy of having the sex issue raised if he can’t keep his pants on.”
Hart’s comparison to JFK wasn’t limited to his youth and healthy head of hair. His healthy libido had long been the focus of rumors, and they were resurfacing as his second campaign got underway.
“Follow me around,” Hart told the New York Times. “I don’t care. I’m serious. If anybody wants to put a tail on me, go ahead. They’d be very bored.”
advertisement
By then, the Miami Herald — acting on an anonymous tip that Hart would be meeting a Florida woman at his D.C. townhouse — was tailing the candidate. On May 3, the same day the NYT printed those words, the Herald had its own story about Hart spending the night with a woman who was not his wife.
In the frenzy that followed, no one was bored. On May 8, Hart withdrew as a candidate. “Clearly, under the present circumstances, this campaign cannot go on,” he told the media crowd back in Colorado. “I refuse to submit my family and my friends and innocent people and myself to further rumors and gossip. It’s simply an intolerable situation.” Paraphrasing Thomas Jefferson, he added: “I tremble for my country when I think we may, in fact, get the kind of leaders we deserve.”
And the media we deserved? The stories didn’t stop. The woman spotted by the Miami Herald was Donna Rice, who’d met Hart at a New Year’s Eve party in Aspen, then met him again on an overnight trip from Miami to Bimini on an 83-foot luxury yacht named the Monkey Business. A photo from that trip, with Rice sitting on Hart’s lap, soon landed on the cover of the National Enquirer; the name of the boat (emblazoned on a T-shirt that Hart was wearing in the picture) inspired jokes from Johnny Carson.
Hart didn’t go down with the ship entirely. He re-entered the presidential campaign in December 1987, then withdrew after a poor showing in New Hampshire. By then, longtime U.S. Rep. Pat Schroeder, his original campaign co-chair, had taken a look at her own presidential race, then tearfully announced she was ending it that September. Joe Biden, who’d been elected senator from Delaware in 1972, dropped out that month, too, after allegations of plagiarism and academic exaggerations hit his campaign. Massachusetts Gov. Michael Dukakis became the 1988 Democratic candidate, losing to George H.W. Bush.
advertisement
advertisement

After his time in politics, Gary Hart continued to consult and write.
Getty Images
Then came President Bill Clinton, and the Monica Lewinsky scandal.
“It’s always been a staple of journalism that if people read it or listen to it, they think it’s important, and people demonstrated that they didn’t think so,” Hart told Westword in 2008. “Are people fascinated by a president’s sex life? Yes. Do they think it’s important to his job? Apparently, a lot of them didn’t think so. So I think that caused a real recalibration in newsrooms. Hopefully we’ll go back to the standard where what’s reportable is only what affects a person’s ability to do their job.”
On Election Day 2018 — two years after Americans elevated Donald Trump, a man who’d bragged about being able to “grab ’em by the pussy,” to the presidency — “The Frontrunner,” a movie about Hart’s 1987 candidacy, was released. “By today’s standards, the Hart ‘scandal’ is almost quaint,” his former aide, Bill Shore, once wrote. “Hart didn’t lie or ask anyone else to. There were no investigations because other than questionable personal judgment, there was nothing to investigate.”
advertisement
By then, Hart had gone on to a distinguished career as a consultant and author. Rice is now president of Enough is Enough, a nonprofit dedicated to making the internet safer for children and families.
But not politicians. Today, when a CEO is out because of an affair with a Chinese spy, many other campaigns have been sunk by sexual shenanigans, and anyone can take a pic of a politician out in public engaging in monkey business, the Hart scandal has moved beyond quaint to what-the-hell-were-they-all-thinking?
We get what we deserve.
Have a suggestion for a story for this series? Send it to [email protected]. In the meantime, read these other 50 for 50 installments:
“1977: Here comes the sun”
“1978: Denver’s Gang of 19 inspires a movement”
“1979: The curtain rises at the DCPA”
“1980: The Cable Cowboys ride the airwaves”
“1981: Viva la Raza”
“1982: Downtown Denver got malled”
“1983: Imagining a great city”
“1984: Denver tops out”
“1985: War of the words over Sand Creek Massacre”
“1986: The Mile High City laid low”

